Categories
Journal

Would You Rather

Would you rather have gates on your alley OR £18,519 to spend on making your alley a better place to play, grow, navigate the city? 

Belfast City Council have publicly announced (via Belfast Live) an open consultation for Phase 5 of alley gates. We mapped the list included within the article which amounts to 27 alleyways across the city. We also note that some of these alleyways have already been gated. The budget for this is £500,000 (an average of £18,519 per alley!). So far the city has spent more than £3,000,000 of ratepayers’ contributions on alley gates. 

We have called for an evaluation of phases 1-4 so that evidence can be gathered to show if gates actually work or if they are (what councillors have described to us as) ‘a sticking plaster’ or ‘a panacea’

From our observations over the past 3 years, we can see that in a small number of gated alleys, the community has gathered to transform the alley into a beautiful communal space. However, we’ve seen many more instances where behind the gates lies disarray. We’ve also witnessed many great examples of ungated alleys that are a pleasure to be in thanks to the neighbours.

Alleyways that are adopted by Department of Infrastructure, as most in Belfast are, are public highways, and therefore technically, rights of way.  So, too, are any alleys that are used by residents and (critically) others as a route. Belfast City Council is duty bound to assert, protect and keep rights of way open and free from obstruction. This is one of the council’s most important duties under the Access (NI) Order, 1983. Blocking these routes with locked gates contravenes that order. 

20220326 9ft in Common 016.jpg

We would like Belfast City Council and city residents to consider the options other than gates that may help solve common alleyway issues. What if, instead of being gated, the alleys were instead seen as a vital contributor instead to the city’s currently fragmented green infrastructure?  A safe and traffic-free walking and cycling route; a place to gather and to play.  

Our ideas are developed based on the premise that more populated, well-lit, visible, overlooked and cared for alleys are going to act as deterrents to anti-social behaviour. 

We have been asking, as part of this investigation, whether there are other, more creative and cost-effective ways to make the alleys safer and reduce anti-social behaviour.  What can we do to avoid adding more locked gates to a city like Belfast, which already has far too many walls and fences between people, and are none too easy to take down?

We question whether a more holistic response to each alley can be developed according to the needs of the residents? Have a look at our ideas and if you want to tell us about your alley, we’d love to listen!

2 replies on “Would You Rather”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.